Grasshopper Pie Cupcakes

Check it ooooout!

55 Degrees!

It’s in the 50s in Orlando today! Eeeee!

Temperatures in the 50s means it’s sweater-wearin’ weather.

Bustin' Out the Sweatahs!

I feel warm and cuddly today. šŸ˜€

My Mother’s Daughter

I will never forget the moment my Aunt Laurie told me she knew I was my mother’s daughter.

I was staying with my aunt and uncle in Raleigh a couple of years ago. I was the first one up in the morning and wandered into the kitchen to fix myself some breakfast.

Then, I saw it. Chocolate bundt cake.

Perfect a.m. fuel, no?

My aunt came into the kitchen at the exact moment I stuck a forkful of the chocolate cake in my mouth.

“Cake for breakfast?” she said. “You really are your mother’s daughter.”

Apparently a hankering for baked goods before 9 a.m. is not uncommon in my family.


Baked goods found their way into my breakfast this morning!

Grasshopper Pie Cupcake

That, my friends, is a grasshopper pie cupcake.

And that, my friends, was my breakfast (x2!). šŸ˜€

Grasshopper Pie Cupcakes

Those of you who share my affinity for mint chocolate chip ice cream will surely enjoy this little creation.

I never heard of grasshopper pie until the Cake vs. Pie March Madness competition heated up at my work several months ago. One of the pies in the running was grasshopper pie. For those of you in the dark about this pie like I was, grasshopper pie is essentially a chilled mint pie with a chocolate cookie crust.

One of my coworkers is celebrating her birthday next week when I will be out on my fall-back honeymoon (more details to come!), and her boyfriend told me she has a strong affinity for grasshopper pie. Since I wasn’t sure how a chilled pie would hold up at work, I opted to make her favorite dessert in cupcake form.

First it was time to make the cupcakes.

I made a batch of chocolate cupcakes using Duncan Hines Butter Recipe Fudge cake mix.

Batter Up!

When making cakes from a box mix, I much prefer mixes that call for the addition of butter rather than oil to the mix. I find them more moist, flavorful and fluffy.

I mixed the cake mix, eggs, water and butter for the full four minutes required until the batter was airy and light.

I then placed the batter in cupcake tins and baked them according to the directions on the box.

Chocolate Cupcakes

Apparently I dispensed a little too much batter into the cupcakes, because they overflowed a bit.


I actually had to cut them out of the pan (and eat the remaining scraps, naturally).

Cupcake Wreckage

I let the cupcakes cool before filling them with a creamy mint filling.

Fill 'Er Up

I made the mint filling by following this recipe from A Good Appetite, though I made four times the amount called for in that recipe.

Then it was time for the big guns… mint buttercream icing!

To make the icing, I made a standard buttercream icing, but added peppermint extract and a tiny bit of green food coloring to the mix.

Mint Buttercream Icing

Mint Buttercream Icing


  • 1 c. butter (2 sticks)
  • 4-5 cups powdered sugar
  • 1/4 cup milk (I used 2 percent)
  • 1/8 – 1/4 teaspoon peppermint extract (add little by little until you get the level of mint flavor you desire)
  • 2 drops green food coloring


  • Beat butter for about two minutes,Ā  or until creamy
  • Add 4 c. powdered sugar, milk, food coloring and peppermint extract and beat until combines
  • Beat in additional cup of powdered sugar

Once the buttercream icing was ready, I let it chill in the fridge for about 10 minutes so it would be easier to work with when I was ready to frost my cupcakes.

After icing the cupcakes, I garnished each little cake with a quarter of a York peppermint patty.

Grasshopper Pie Cupcakes Garnished with York Peppermint Patties

Then it was time for the best part… Eating! šŸ˜€

Eat Me!

A Peek Inside

If you or one of your loved ones are a fan of chocolate and mint, please add these cupcakes to your “must make” list.

I want to make them again around Christmas and dye half of the mint buttercream red and garnish the red cupcakes with chopped candy cane pieces. Holiday fun! šŸ˜€

Last night Sadie and I ate our bodyweight in the mint buttercream icing. By the time Ryan got home from work, Sadie was doing laps around our apartment and I was jumping around in a kitchen that looked like it had been hit by a hurricane.

It was a good night… and it’s been a good morning. How could it not be when the day starts with two cupcakes? šŸ˜‰


  1. Britannie says

    I’m INSANELY jealous that your sweater weather is 55 degrees. In the good ol’ Chicago area its a solid 32 degrees, not fun haha šŸ™‚


  2. Marty says

    These cupcakes look delicious…glad your honeymoon plans are starting to fall into place. I don’t many people who would have stayed as positive as you have through all of this. By the way it has been snowing here in Michigan since early this morning šŸ™‚


  3. jamie creative cupcakes says

    I love mint. These cupcakes look amazing. I could also eat them for breakfast. – lunch and idnner too.


  4. Kate says

    Cake for breakfast can’t be too far off from a muffin for breakfast, right? Have you ever tried the pumpkin in lieu of oil & eggs trick? It makes pretty dense, but still moist cupcakes, but at least there is a bit of added nutrition. Just dump the box chocolate cake mix and add a can of pumpkin. Easy! You can also use a can of cola or diet cola, too!



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *