Peanut Butter Fingers

Living a Life Fueled by Healthy Food and Fitness

Navigation
  • Home
  • About
    • Contact
    • Who’s Who
    • All About NASM
    • Disclaimer
    • Wedding
  • Recipe Index
  • Workouts
  • Pregnancy
    • Pregnancy + Baby #2
    • Pregnancy + Baby #3
    • Miscarriages
  • Baby
  • Shop + Favs
    • My Amazon Shop
    • Codes + Discounts
    • Books
    • Blogging
  • Travel
    • Orlando & Florida
    • Blog Travel

Peppermint Cookies ‘n’ Cream Ice Cream

December 13, 2020 by Julie 13 Comments

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

This recipe for Peppermint Cookies ‘n’ Cream Ice Cream is a holiday delight packed with crunchy cookie pieces and speckled with peppermint candies. Made with a whole milk and heavy cream base, it’s a creamy treat worthy of a special occasion. Thank you to Dairy Farmers of America for sponsoring this post! 

Peppermint Cookies n Cream Ice Cream

On my birthday this past year, I received an ice cream maker from Ryan. If you’ve been reading this blog for a while now, you know ice cream is my favorite food. By far. It takes the cake above all other food by a landslide, and just thinking about a cold, creamy bowl of ice cream is enough to make me feel a little giddy. My affinity for ice cream runs deep.

Peppermint Cookies n Cream Ice Cream

Naturally, after receiving a new ice cream maker, I became a little obsessed with making homemade ice cream. I’d love to blame this on the fact that I was in the third trimester of my pregnancy in the heat of the summer, but that would be a blatant lie. I want ice cream regardless of the outside temperatures and regardless of whether or not I’m growing a tiny human in my belly. I had a lot of homemade ice cream successes, most notably a batch of cookies ‘n’ cream that was jam-packed with so many cookies it put the store bought versions to shame.

Now that we’re smack-dab in the middle of the holiday season, my desire to make festive ice cream flavors has kicked into high gear. I’ve been experimenting with eggnog ice cream made with crushed Biscoff cookies (oh my gosh, so good), gingerbread ice cream (this one I need to work on) and, the recipe I’m sharing with you guys today, Peppermint Cookies ‘n’ Cream Ice Cream.

We’re talking tons of crunchy cookie pieces swirled into a refreshingly minty-vanilla ice cream base that’s so good even Santa would bypass a plate of cookies in favor of a bowl of this holiday magic.

Here’s everything you need to make it:

  • PET® Dairy Whole Milk
  • PET Heavy Whipping Cream
  • Peppermint Extract
  • Vanilla Extract
  • Candy Canes or Peppermints
  • Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

There are a few non-negotiables for me when it comes to making homemade ice cream. Most important, for me, is using some combination of whole milk, heavy whipping cream or half ‘n’ half as the base. Icy ice cream is my biggest pet peeve so I’m not willing to chance it with ingredients that might yield a less-than-creamy ice cream base.

Peppermint Cookies n Cream Ice Cream

For this batch of peppermint cookies ‘n’ cream ice cream, I used a combination of farm-fresh whole milk and heavy whipping cream from PET® Dairy, which is farmer-owned and sources its milk from family farms in our region. One family farm in the Charlotte area that supplies milk to PET is Sand Hills Dairy, a third-generation dairy farm run by Scott and Kitty Mayer in Newberry, South Carolina. Started as Mayer Farms in 1949, the family has grown the farm and welcomed more family into their business along the way. Knowing that PET’s milks, creams and eggnogs I see on the shelves at the grocery store near me might have come from the Mayer Family is pretty darn cool and makes scooping up a bowl of this peppermint cookies ‘n’ cream ice cream feel a little more special!

Integrated into the milk and cream base is a bunch of finely crushed peppermints (or candy canes!) that give the ice cream a subtle pink hue and a whole lot of refreshing peppermint flavor. I used a food processor to crush the peppermints but if you choose to crush them by hand, make sure you really put some elbow grease behind it because you want them almost powder-like in consistency.

Peppermint Cookies n Cream Ice Cream

And then there’s the cookies. LOTS of cookies. I didn’t skimp on the cookies because cookies ‘n’ cream ice cream without a lot of cookie chunks might as well be plain ol’ vanilla if you ask me. I want the cookies to be the star and not fade into the background, ya know?

Once the ice cream is all churned up and beautifully thick and creamy, you’ll want to freeze it for 8 hours (or overnight) so it has time to harden just a bit and become perfectly scoopable. This is not the kind of ice cream that will come out rock-hard after 8 hours though. It has the kind of texture I like to refer to as “ice cream you immediately eat right after you bring it home from the grocery store” consistency which, for me, is my all-time favorite. It’s hard enough to maintain its shape when scooped but soft enough to taste almost whipped but still oh so creamy. I want some more of THAT in my life every day, please!

Peppermint Cookies n Cream Ice Cream

Regardless of whether it’s 70 degrees where you are or 30 degrees in your hometown, I hope this peppermint cookies ‘n’ cream ice cream makes your holiday season a little sweeter!

Peppermint Cookies ‘n’ Cream Ice Cream

Print
clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon

Peppermint Cookies ‘n’ Cream Ice Cream

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star 5 from 2 reviews
  • Author: Julie
Print Recipe
Pin Recipe

Description

This Peppermint Cookies ‘n’ Cream Ice Cream is a cold and creamy holiday delight packed with crunchy cookie pieces.


Ingredients

Scale
  • 2 cups PET heavy whipping cream
  • 1 cup PET whole milk
  • 4 ounces very finely crushed peppermint candies or candy canes (approximately 22 crushed Starlight Mints) + additional 1/4 cup finely chopped peppermints (for garnish, if desired)
  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 3/4 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1/8 teaspoon peppermint extract
  • 2 dozen chocolate sandwich cookies, crushed

Instructions

  1. Combine heavy whipping cream, whole milk, 4 ounces crushed peppermint candies (see note below!), sugar, vanilla and peppermint extract in a large mixing bowl and whisk together vigorously until everything is combined and sugar is no longer grainy in the mix. (Letting it sit for 30 minutes in the refrigerator and then whisking it again — or blending in a high-powdered blender — helps the sugar dissolve well.)
  2. Pour into ice cream maker and churn for approximately 30 minutes, or until ice cream begins to thicken and become very creamy.
  3. Pour crushed cookies into the ice cream and allow to churn for an additional 5 minutes.
  4. Using a spatula, transfer the mixture into a baking dish (I used a typical loaf pan) and cover. Freeze for at least 8 hours or, ideally, overnight.
  5. Remove from the freezer and scoop into bowls. Garnish with additional cookies and crushed peppermint (if desired) and enjoy!

Notes

If your peppermint candies do not dissolve into the creamy mixture and begin to clump together, you may need to transfer the mixture into a high-powered blender to make sure no clumps remain.

Did you make this recipe?

Tag @pbfingers on Instagram

Peppermint Cookies n Cream Ice Cream

Be sure to follow PBFingers on Instagram and Facebook!

I'd love to connect with you! I am always so grateful when you let me know you tried one of my recipes or workouts and tag me in your photos or updates. Thank you so much!!!

Filed Under: Desserts/Sweet Treats, Holiday Recipes, Ice Cream Recipes, Recipes Tagged With: cookies 'n' cream, dessert, holiday recipe, holiday recipes, ice cream, ice cream recipe, ice cream recipes, peppermint cookies n cream, peppermint cookies n cream ice cream, peppermint ice cream

About Julie

My name is Julie and I am a full-time blogger, new mama, fitness enthusiast (certified personal trainer and group exercise instructor) and food fanatic (mostly healthy... but also not-so-healthy) living in North Carolina with my husband, dog and baby boy. Thank you for visiting Peanut Butter Fingers! I hope you enjoy little glimpses into my life and have fun trying the sweaty workouts I frequently share and making some of my favorite recipes along the way!

« Things I’m Loving Friday #353
Holiday Blow Ups, Botanical Garden Lights and Christmas Trivia »

Comments

  1. Amy says

    December 13, 2020 at 8:48 pm

    Made this tonight and delicious.. however the crushed peppermints ended up clumping together quite a bit, even after trying to separate it after having it sit and whisked. Not sure if you have any recommendations?

    Reply
    • Julie says

      December 16, 2020 at 4:37 pm

      Hi Amy! So sorry for my delayed response — your comment initially went to spam! Anyway, first, I’m so glad you thought the recipe was delicious. I’m sorry you had issues with the peppermint clumping. My best advice if this happens again is to transfer the mixture to a high-powered blender before pouring into into your ice cream maker to make sure it’s all very smooth. I also apprecaite your comment and updated the recipe with this little tip just in case anyone else runs into this issue!

      Reply
  2. Katrina says

    December 13, 2020 at 9:41 pm

    At one point you said eggs were needed but they aren’t in the actual recipe. Are they needed?

    Reply
    • Julie says

      December 14, 2020 at 8:43 am

      No! Sorry about that — the recipe, as written, is correct! I initially created this recipe off a cookies n cream one I shared on the blog earlier and it had eggs so that list was just out of habit but I didn’t use them in this recipe at all!

      Reply
  3. Richard Tunner says

    December 13, 2020 at 11:00 pm

    I am a big fan of the recipe! Loved it a lot! Thank you!

    Reply
  4. Julie says

    December 14, 2020 at 10:00 am

    I grew up in Newberry, SC! So cool. This recipe looks DELICIOUS!! Thanks for sharing❤️

    Reply
    • Julie says

      December 14, 2020 at 11:35 am

      Oh that’s awesome!! And hope you enjoy the recipe!! 💗

      Reply
  5. Becca says

    December 15, 2020 at 9:15 am

    Julie – can you post a link to the ice cream maker you have? I’ve been searching but can’t seem to find it. Thanks so much!

    Reply
    • Julie says

      December 15, 2020 at 11:38 am

      yes! we have the cuisinart ice cream maker and it’s fabulous!! https://bit.ly/3mfm2Nq

      Reply
  6. Jenny says

    December 16, 2020 at 10:04 am

    What kind of container do you use to put your ice cream in, to freeze? I’m hoping to get an ice cream maker for the holiday and I keep saving all your yummy recipes!

    Reply
    • Julie says

      December 16, 2020 at 1:17 pm

      I use these Rubbermaid Brilliance Glass containers and they’re awesome!! https://bit.ly/2Lxjygz I love the way the tops create a tight, leak-proof seal, at that size is great for ice cream. Also, full disclosure, I am working with Rubbermaid on an Instagram campaign but truly love the product and they’ve become my go-to storage containers!

      Reply
  7. Sherry says

    December 22, 2020 at 1:19 pm

    Made this yesterday and planned to keep it to serve on Christmas but we couldn’t stop eating it!!! It was SO good and the cookie to ice cream ratio was perfect. Looks like we have to make another batch for Christmas!

    Reply
  8. Michelle says

    December 31, 2020 at 1:18 am

    LOVE this recipe! I followed pretty much to a T but didn’t add the peppermint extract – I think the peppermint candy gives the perfect amount of peppermint flavor. I’ve only ever made ice cream with the custard/egg base, and this was so much easier and faster, but just as creamy and rich. Since there’s no such thing as too many cookies, I topped the tub of ice cream with extra crushed cookies 😉 Thanks for such a yummy recipe, Julie!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe rating 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

Hi! I’m Julie and I am a mom to three energetic boys and a personal trainer and blogger living in Charlotte, North Carolina. Welcome to my blog! Peanut Butter Fingers follows my life and my interests in food, fitness, family, travel and (mostly) healthy living.
NEVER MISS A POST!
FacebookTwitterInstagramPinterestBloglovin
Follow

Search

Fashion Favorites

Beauty Favorites

Items I Swear By

Kid Favorites

Shop My Baby Essentials

Quick Links

  • Favorite Posts
  • Recipe Index
  • Workouts
  • Fashion
  • Pregnancy/Baby
  • Family

Recent Posts

  • Week of Weeknight Meals: June 2025
  • Things I’m Loving Friday #558
  • Recent Looks: #11
  • Week of Workouts: June 2025
  • Things I’m Loving Friday #557

Categories

Archives

Disclaimer

I am not a registered dietitian. My blog is simply a documentation of my life. The views I express are mine alone, based on my own experiences, and should not be taken as medical advice. I DO NOT post everything I eat. Though I am a certified personal trainer, the workouts I post may not be right for you. Please speak with a medical professional before making any changes to your current routine.

Affiliates

Please note that affiliate links may pop up on PBF from time to time. I greatly appreciate your support!
Privacy Policy

Copyright � 2013 Peanut Butter Fingers / Julie Fagan. All Rights Reserved.
Blog Designed by SWOON CREATIVE