Chocolate and peanut butter are a match made in heaven. I find myself pairing the two together on an almost daily basis. Chocolate peanut butter smoothies. Dates topped with peanut butter and a sprinkle of chocolate chips. Cocoa oatmeal with melted peanut butter. Chocolate peanut butter banana soft serve.
So why not chocolate peanut butter chia seed pudding!?
I’ve shared a handful of chia seed pudding recipes on the blog before and feel like I am continually playing around with different flavor combinations and ingredients. I think it’s time we gave chocolate and peanut butter the chia seed pudding spotlight.
Chia seed pudding has been a favorite of mine for years. I love it for breakfast, a mid-morning snack and dessert and this chocolate peanut butter chia seed pudding has quickly become my go-to recipe. You can change things up and use your favorite nut butter in place of the peanut butter, but I like to keep it classic and typically opt for creamy or crunchy peanut butter.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Chia Seed Pudding

Chocolate Peanut Butter Chia Seed Pudding
- Prep Time: 2 minutes
- Total Time: 2 minutes
- Yield: 2 servings 1x
- Category: breakfast, recipes
Description
This recipe for chocolate peanut butter chia seed pudding is a delicious dairy-free dessert made with fiber-rich chia seeds, creamy peanut butter and cacao powder and is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth in a healthy way.
Ingredients
- 1/4 cup chia seeds
- 2 tablespoons + 1 teaspoon cacao powder
- 1 tablespoon honey or maple syrup
- 1 tablespoon peanut butter (plus more for topping)
- 1 1/4 cup unsweetened coconut milk
Instructions
- Combine all ingredients in a small bowl and stir together
- Refrigerate until mixture thickens, approximately two hours (or overnight)
- Stir chia seed pudding, top with a drizzle of melted peanut butter and enjoy
I owe a big thank you to LuckyVitamin for replenishing my chia seed supply and sending me the ingredients I used to make this recipe!
Chia Seeds // Peanut Butter & Co. Smooth Operator Peanut Butter // Cacao Powder
Blog reader Leah works for the company and when she first reached out to me about the third-generation owned family business, I quickly became impressed with LuckyVitamin’s website and product offerings. They have everything from super-healthy organic foods to natural skin care and beauty products, as well as 40,000+ health and wellness products at up to 75 percent off retail prices with super fast shipping (free on orders $49+). And if you decide to order something from the site, LuckyVitamin offers a 90 Day Happiness Guarantee where you may return anything from your order if you simply don’t like it, whether it is opened or not!
The organization of the site is actually super helpful, as you can sort by brand, health concerns (allergies, inflammation, etc.), specialty (gluten-free, cruelty-free, non-GMO, etc.) and their latest deals. (FYI, one of their current deals is for Mrs. Meyer’s cleaning products which we love in our house!)
I had no trouble selecting a handful of my usual staples from their site to use to make this chia seed pudding and couldn’t resist browsing around the site and loading up on some of our favorite household cleaning and baby products. Thank you so much to Leah and the LuckyVitamin team for such a fun package!
The Honest Company Honest Wipes // Boudreaux’s Butt Paste
Mrs. Meyer’s Everyday Surface Cleaner (Honeysuckle) // Mrs. Meyer’s Lavender Dish Soap
LuckyVitamin Giveaway
I must also thank LuckyVitamin for offering one PBF reader a $100 gift card to use toward anything on their site!
To be entered into this giveaway, please leave a comment on this post, telling me about one thing you’d likely purchase from LuckyVitamin.com if you won. Would you load up on some healthy food? Restock your cleaning supplies? Please let me know!
I will randomly select a winner on Friday.
Good luck!
I would get some healthy food!
baby necessities and cleaning supplies! i’m sure i wouldn’t be able to check out without a few snack items too.
I’d probably do some new cleaning supplies and maybe try a new healthy snack!
I would restock my pantry with a number of health items-starting with nuts and nut butter!!
FOOD! definitely food! i would stock up on some nut butters, like this Manna Butter Cashew Cacao Cookie Dough – how amazing does that sound!?
I would use the gift card to scope out some natural skin care products (Buffalo winters are tough on skin!) and restock my cleaning supplies! My husband and I love the Meyers cleaning products.
There are a lot of things I would like to try! I think I would get a mix of cleaning supplies and some foods like chia seeds.
Cleaning supplies
I would get some cleaning supplies and then treat myself with fancy peanut butter.
I would stock up on tea and cleaning supplies!
Hi Julie! Great recipe–I’m thinking about making it with almond butter so it’s paleo-friendly. Can’t wait!! I would most likely buy cleaning supplies and nut butter from the site. Those are two things that add up quickly, and as a student they can put a dent in my wallet!
I would definitely stock up on more chia seeds as I’m constantly running out!!
I would love to restock my cleaning supplies with some more natural brands! And that chia seed pudding recipe sounds delicious!
I would definitely stock up on some household cleaners (and would sneak in a few healthy treats for me)!
We are in desperate need for some new cleaning supplies over here! And any extra money would go towards nut butter of all kinds – you can never have too much!
For sure some Meyers cleaning items-best smelling stuff around! And some all natural dog treats 🙂
I would stock up on cleaning supplies – the Mrs. Myers line of products smell so good!
I love to keep a clean house and hearing how wonderful Mrs. Myers products are I would get some of those but make sure to through in a treat…or two for myself 🙂
I’d definitely load up on some pantry staples. So many to choose from!
I would definitely be replacing my cleaning supplies! I’m trying to make the switch over to all CLEAN cleaning supplies so as my other products are finishing, I’m replacing them. What a perfect opportunity to make the jump and go all in!
Restock post whole30, especially nut items!
I would definitely stock up on vitamins/probiotics. It’s always an expensive grocery trip when I run out of these!
I would stock up on Mrs. Meyer’s cleaning supplies!!!! I know it sounds weird but you have to try the “Basil” scent! Especially in the hand soap and every day spray cleaner. It smells so so amazing!!
Health items such as cacao powder, nut butters, and coconut products 🙂
I can’t wait to try this recipe! It sounds delish.
You are right – the LuckyVitamin website rocks. I originally thought I’d stock up on good foods, but after visiting the website I am so tempted by the Personal Care stuff. The lotions look awesome!!
I’ve never tried natural cleaning supplies before and I REALLY want to! I’m sure I could find a million things to purchase on that site! This pudding looks amazing, I LOVE chia pudding especially with peanut butter!
Everything on the site looks great! I was particularly drawn to the natural beauty products.
My husband and I always buy protein powder from their website because we can find the clean, healthy non-artificial sweetener varieties we love. I would also buy food and consider the items to make your recipe!
I would restock my cleaning supplies! I just had a baby so I’m looking for more natural products, and it looks like I wouldn’t have a problem at all getting it from Lucky Vitamin.
I would definitely stock up on yummy foods!
I would stock up on everything! Such a great selection of food items and cleaning products that I already love!
I would love to get some quality protein powder and vitamins
I would get lots of natural cleaning supplies, and maybe some yummy gluten free staples 🙂
Certainly some cleaning supplies, and then something healthy and sweet as a treat once the cleaning is done 😛
Peanut butter!!
I would love to try the cleaning supplies!
Cleaning supplies!! I have recently been trying to revamp my cleaning supplies to more natural products. I also would re-stock some food as well.. Love but butters!
My first thought was “Oh I would definitely get cleaning supplies!” But then I looked at the website and holy cow they have an acupressure mat! I have been wanting one forever! So I would also get one of those!
Vega Protein & Greens!!
I’ve always wanted to try out the cleaning supplies!
I would definitely stock up on some protein powders and nuts to make my own nut butters!
I would love to restock my Myers cleaning products. But more important I have never had chia seed pudding!! and I too love anything w the peanut butter and chocolate combo.
I really need to restock my pantry, and would love to fill it with healthier choices! Then I could try that chia seed pudding!
Hmm…most likely healthy food (nut butters!!) and maybe a few cleaning products….
I would restock my cleaning supplies!!
A mix of both healthy food & cleaning products. Love Meyer’s products!
I’d love to stock up on some healthy pantry items and some baby items as well!
I shouldn’t have looked at the site because now I want everything! I think I would stock up on health foods though.
I see they have perfect bars – I would definitely stock up on those!
i would def stock up on chia seeds! love them!